PDA

View Full Version : John McCain's War On Political Speech



Pale Rider
01-14-2008, 12:07 PM
John McCain's War On Political Speech


How the Arizona senator and other campaign finance reformers use the law to muffle critics and trample the First Amendment


by Bradley A. Smith
originally written for ReasonOnline.

Polls consistently show that campaign finance reform is an extremely low priority for most Americans. It's not an issue that Americans wake up thinking about, even while pondering politics. It may seem like an obscure regulatory system that has very little effect on our daily lives, or even our political lives. But it's an assault on the First Amendment and a transfer of power from citizens to incumbent politicians, one that doesn't address far more serious conflicts of interest, including those of politicians who bang the campaign finance drum the loudest. As I step down as chairman of the Federal Election Commission, I fear that the regulatory machinery set in motion by Sens. John McCain and Russ Feingold will be used to further grind down the free expression of individual citizens.

Before I discuss this, here is a very limited overview of what we call the limits, prohibitions, and reporting requirements of the Federal Election Campaign Act, or FECA.

FECA's provisions create a very complex matrix that depends on who is giving to whom. But to oversimplify, individuals can give a candidate no more than $2,200 per election; a political action committee (or PAC), which is merely a group of people pooling their small contributions, can give up to $5,000 to a candidate per election; and an individual can give up to $5,000 to a PAC per year. There are other limits on how much you can give to political parties, and there are overall limits on how much a person can give in a two-year period, but to keep this simple I want to focus on contributions by people to candidates. The list of prohibitions also includes bans on direct contributions by corporations, labor organizations, federal contractors, or foreign nationals to candidates and committees. Additionally the law prohibits the conversion of campaign funds for personal use, and then there are a wide variety of reporting requirements, things that have to be reported to the federal government, including the name, address, and occupation of donors contributing over $200 -- creating a sort of federal database of citizen political activity.

In the legislative record there is considerable evidence that many supporters of McCain-Feingold specifically wanted the law to silence criticism of their own performance in office. The act includes a provision that prohibits most citizen groups, such as the National Rifle Association, the Sierra Club, and Planned Parenthood, from making any broadcast advertisements within 60 days of an election that even mention a candidate for federal office.

You can easily find quotes from across the political spectrum explaining why members of Congress find the speech of these citizen groups distasteful. But for brevity's sake, let's focus on Sen. McCain. These groups, he once said, "often run ads that the candidates themselves disapprove of." What a horrible thought: citizens running ads that candidates disapprove of.

Sen. McCain went on: "Further, these ads are almost always negative attack ads, and do little to further beneficial debate and healthy political dialogue." Now, when Sen. McCain called my colleague on the FEC, Ellen Weintraub, "corrupt" merely because she disagreed with him on the proper interpretation of the law, I don't think that necessarily promoted healthy political dialogue. But should he be banned from saying it? No.

Story continues here... (http://www.gunowners.org/mcwar.htm)

5stringJeff
01-14-2008, 05:51 PM
I've said it before and I'll say it again: McCain's "campaign finance reform" is the worst law since the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798. And that incorporates things like Prohibition, welfare, the New Deal, etc.

Pale Rider
01-15-2008, 01:14 AM
I've said it before and I'll say it again: McCain's "campaign finance reform" is the worst law since the Alien and Sedition Acts of 1798. And that incorporates things like Prohibition, welfare, the New Deal, etc.

People should get their face away from the TV set and start doing some real research on mccain. It won't take them long to find out that this the guy is a real liberal asswad.

You wouldn't believe all the "Ron Paul" bumper stickers and yard signs around Reno Jeff. I wouldn't be surprized if RP has a real good showing in Nevada. I do believe I'm going to vote for him in our primary.

Pale Rider
01-20-2008, 05:03 PM
"Bump"... I think manu wants to read this.