PDA

View Full Version : Sunday's HC bill will pass Senate HC bill and modify it???



Little-Acorn
03-20-2010, 12:23 PM
That's the gist of the bill the House it going to try to pass on Sunday. It does two things:

1.) It will "deem" the Senate's HC bill as "passed".
2.) It will pass a series of modifications to that Senate HC bill.

Well, guess what, sports fans. That means that the House is passing a DIFFERENT bill from what the Senate passed, since the House is modifying the bill.

That means the Senate must now approve the modifications in this Sunday bill... or else there will be nothing for the President to sign.

Even if this "deeming" of "passage" was somehow Constitutional, the addition of modifications to the Senate bill by the House, makes it un-signable by the President.

The Constitution requires that the House and Senate pass the SAME, IDENTICAL bill, to be able to send it to the President for his signature.

The House shell-game masters seem to be pretending that if the bill deeming passage, has a set of modifications next to it in the same bill, then somehow the bill isn't modified for signing purposes, but IS modified for House-passage purposes.

Can anybody figure out these bizarre pretzel twists Nancy Pelosi is going through, to put forth this amazing charade?

Sorry, Nancy. If your bill modifies the Senate HC bill, then it's NOT the same bill the Senate passed.

Back to the drawing board, Dems. You just shot yourselves in the foot with this attempted stunt.

KarlMarx
03-20-2010, 01:08 PM
1. Doesn't this make the bill vulnerable to a court challenge?

2. Doesn't this provide grounds for articles of impeachment against Nancy Pelosi and perhaps the president?

I think the answer to the first question is "certainly" and the answer to the second questin is "probably".

Little-Acorn
03-20-2010, 01:13 PM
1. Doesn't this make the bill vulnerable to a court challenge?
Completely.


2. Doesn't this provide grounds for articles of impeachment against Nancy Pelosi and perhaps the president?
It would have to take a number and stand in a LONG line.

Kathianne
03-20-2010, 03:30 PM
That's the gist of the bill the House it going to try to pass on Sunday. It does two things:

1.) It will "deem" the Senate's HC bill as "passed".
2.) It will pass a series of modifications to that Senate HC bill.

Well, guess what, sports fans. That means that the House is passing a DIFFERENT bill from what the Senate passed, since the House is modifying the bill.

That means the Senate must now approve the modifications in this Sunday bill... or else there will be nothing for the President to sign.

Even if this "deeming" of "passage" was somehow Constitutional, the addition of modifications to the Senate bill by the House, makes it un-signable by the President.

The Constitution requires that the House and Senate pass the SAME, IDENTICAL bill, to be able to send it to the President for his signature.

The House shell-game masters seem to be pretending that if the bill deeming passage, has a set of modifications next to it in the same bill, then somehow the bill isn't modified for signing purposes, but IS modified for House-passage purposes.

Can anybody figure out these bizarre pretzel twists Nancy Pelosi is going through, to put forth this amazing charade?

Sorry, Nancy. If your bill modifies the Senate HC bill, then it's NOT the same bill the Senate passed.

Back to the drawing board, Dems. You just shot yourselves in the foot with this attempted stunt.
y
They are not doing the deem & pass, they have the votes so they are going the traditional way.

LiberalNation
03-20-2010, 03:35 PM
good, better that way.

Kathianne
03-20-2010, 03:56 PM
good, better that way.

I think there may well be Constitutional challenges on 'forcing' folks to buy insurance.

red states rule
03-21-2010, 06:18 AM
http://www.foxnews.com/static/managed/img/Opinion/2XcentricMikeTX.brd.JPG

namvet
03-21-2010, 08:23 AM
today is Sunday. their on their knees praying to Osama