O'Reilly Says Possible Sex Abuse Victim Hornbeck Enjoyed Captivity

[stephanie]

I like Bubbles and I think you'll find "he" is a "she".

Oooooops...It must of been the avatar, it looked like a boy....

I have nothing against Bubbles....I'm just sunlight deprived and cranky....

[Bubbalicious]

I didn't say I think Horbeck "got something out of it." I don't think anything yet except that I wouldn't stay against my will from age 11 to 16. I'll wait until I hear the story from both sides before coming to a conclusion.

OK well you're not going to answer the Elizabeth Smart question but the OP wasn't even about what the whole story is with Hornbeck, it's about O'Reilly leaping to his own conclusions and reporting them as if they're tried and true facts. He does that all the time. Plus he's a sicko if he automatically assumes an eleven year old must enjoy being held captive for four years.

[jillian]

Oooooops...It must of been the avatar, it looked like a boy....

I have nothing against Bubbles....I'm just sunlight deprived and cranky....

S'okay, hon!! Maybe we should all chip in and get ya one of those lamps that mimics the sun. We can give ya that and a good bottle of your choosing. You'll be a pussycat in no time.

[stephanie]

OK well you're not going to answer the Elizabeth Smart question but the OP wasn't even about what the whole story is with Hornbeck, it's about Oreilly leaping to his own conclusions and reporting them as if they're tried and true facts. He does that all the time. Plus he's a sicko if he automatically assumes an eleven year old must enjoy being held captive for four years.

I've seen him talking about this case...
I don't see anything in his questions that is inappropriate...He's never said that is his absolute conclusion...
As I said, I've wondered about some of them, Oreilly just spoke them...

He also said if he's wrong he'd apologize....

I'll say this one last time...
Only time will tell..

[manu1959]

OK well you're not going to answer the Elizabeth Smart question but the OP wasn't even about what the whole story is with Hornbeck, it's about O'Reilly leaping to his own conclusions and reporting them as if they're tried and true facts. He does that all the time. Plus he's a sicko if he automatically assumes an eleven year old must enjoy being held captive for four years.

any thing is possible

[Gunny]

OK well you're not going to answer the Elizabeth Smart question but the OP wasn't even about what the whole story is with Hornbeck, it's about O'Reilly leaping to his own conclusions and reporting them as if they're tried and true facts. He does that all the time. Plus he's a sicko if he automatically assumes an eleven year old must enjoy being held captive for four years.

Ummm.... no ..... and no.

I don't recall the specifics of the Elizabeth Smart situation, but IIRC, no real issue of doubt was raised as to whether or not her captivity was voluntary.

O'Relly doesn't report the news. He editorializes already reported news. If you don't like his opinion, fine, but I object to liberals continually stating he "leaps to conclusions and reports them as fact." He is not a news anchor like say Dan Rather , charged with reporting factual events.

[stephanie]

Smokey, hon!! Maybe we should all chip in and get ya one of those lamps that mimics the sun. We can give ya that and a good bottle of your choosing. You'll be a pussycat in no time.

Got one of those lamps and the bottle...

But I thought the sunlight deprived excuse for me being a tad bitchy was a good one...

Thanks for the thoughts, though..

[jillian]

Got one of those lamps and the bottle...

But I thought the sunlight deprived excuse for me being a tad bitchy was a good one...

Thanks for the thoughts, though..

LOL! You are funny, though!

Cheers!

[Pale Rider]

O'Reilly's a nutcase. I thought his comments on Shawn Hornbeck were nothing short of sick.

And besides... O'Reilly is an idiot and deserves it.

Wow Jill... tell us what you REALLY think...

O'Reilly is ONLY the HIGHEST RATED SHOW ON CABLE! Explain that. Oh I know... you and your minority are all the smart ones, and the vast majority are all the stupid ones... riiiiiiiiight.

And I think this kid started to like where he was at too. I personally think Bill is right on. This kid had a bike and rode around. He had a girl friend and went to school dances. He had his own computer and was on the internet. I'm c'mon. He had MANY different ways he could have alerted someone as to his circumstances, AND HE DIDN'T.

I've heard his REAL father was a convicted child molestor. So there's a lot to this story. O'Reilly isn't doing or saying a damn thing wrong. Hard questions need to be asked, and answered.

[jillian]

Wow Jill... tell us what you REALLY think...

Like you, I always do!

O'Reilly is ONLY the HIGHEST RATED SHOW ON CABLE! Explain that. Oh I know... you and your minority are all the smart ones, and the vast majority are all the stupid ones... riiiiiiiiight.

Just cause I think the guy is an idiot, doesn't mean I don't see his entertainment value. I enjoyed watching Colbert wipe the floor with him.

And I think this kid started to like where he was at too. I personally think Bill is right on. This kid had a bike and rode around. He had a girl friend and went to school dances. He had his own computer and was on the internet. I'm c'mon. He had MANY different ways he could have alerted someone as to his circumstances, AND HE DIDN'T.

I've heard his REAL father was a convicted child molestor. So there's a lot to this story. O'Reilly isn't doing or saying a damn thing wrong. Hard questions need to be asked, and answered.

Well, kids do a lot of things out of fear. We don't know what he was told would happen if he left or told anyone. And I think the questions should have been about the animal who kidnapped him, not about the kid. Just my opinion.

As for hard questions, well yeah... of the kidnapper. And I don't think O'Reilly is the one to ask the hard questions anyway.

[Pale Rider]

Like you, I always do!

Here here...

Just cause I think the guy is an idiot, doesn't mean I don't see his entertainment value. I enjoyed watching Colbert wipe the floor with him.

Yeah right...

Well, kids do a lot of things out of fear. We don't know what he was told would happen if he left or told anyone. And I think the questions should have been about the animal who kidnapped him, not about the kid. Just my opinion.

As for hard questions, well yeah... of the kidnapper. And I don't think O'Reilly is the one to ask the hard questions anyway.

Well, he's a pundit, and that's what they do.

[The ClayTaurus]

Like you, I always do!



Just cause I think the guy is an idiot, doesn't mean I don't see his entertainment value. I enjoyed watching Colbert wipe the floor with him.



Well, kids do a lot of things out of fear. We don't know what he was told would happen if he left or told anyone. And I think the questions should have been about the animal who kidnapped him, not about the kid. Just my opinion.

As for hard questions, well yeah... of the kidnapper. And I don't think O'Reilly is the one to ask the hard questions anyway.

The Colbert exchange was entirely overhyped and substandard on both sides.

[jillian]

Here here...


Yeah right...




Well, he's a pundit, and that's what they do.

Heh!

I'm not sure I consider O'Reilly a pundit. Honest, I'm not really sure what I'd call him.

[jillian]

The Colbert exchange was entirely overhyped and substandard on both sides.

I thought he did better with Papa Bear on the Colbert Report.

I love Stephen Colbert!

[stephanie]

I thought he did better with Papa Bear on the Colbert Report.

I love Stephen Colbert!

Now go figure...
I find Colbert too be a pompass ass...