Originally Posted by
Drummond
I don't have any clear understanding on America's situation ... but, here, we differentiate between wartime and peacetime conditions. There is such as thing as aligning a society and its powers in law, to meet emergencies.
I'm having a hard time seeing today's virus situation as being different to a wartime scenario. In war, you have an enemy that means you great harm. Now, Covid-19 may not have consciousness, but its whole reason for being is to act in a destructive fashion, and to 'do harm' ... just as is true of an enemy.
Therefore, we are all 'at war' with Covid-19.
Here, by and large, people understand that special powers must intervene and shape the best response to the virus. This is no less than realistic. You enjoy freedoms, to the extent that they can be afforded. When they can't be afforded, then, they just can't.
Better to suspend freedoms temporarily than to invite mass death to serve an immovable ideology, one not geared to evolve as conditions demand.
I don't know that there's a difference per se. But a LOT of the BS the left has pulled over the years is based on Government intrusion on individual Rights. We do it all the time and just say we don't. The biggest issue in that argument is who/what trumps who/what because there is no real provision to deny us our individual Rights guaranteed by the US Constitution. The government just does it.
Abraham Lincoln and FDR are two perfect examples. They trampled the Constitution and individual Rights for what they perceived as the greater good.
What really gets my knickers in a bunch is when the very people who scream "the law, the Constitution, MY Rights" are perfectly willing to deny others theirs to force them to do things their way when it suits them. This Chinese flu issue has shone the spotlight on this hypocrisy once again.
“When bad men combine, the good must associate; else they will fall, one by one, an unpitied sacrifice in a contemptible struggle.” Edumnd Burke