Are actually trying to delineate between magic and "the supernatural?" Please. Would you be happier if I used the word "wizardry?"
The only debate that matters is the one that includes rational arguments. The "Creator" argument falls flat in this regard. There can be no argument based on a creator because there is nothing to back it up. The only real debates that exist are the ones inside evolutionary theory.
Come up with some corporeal evidence and that will change.