War Powers And Disobeying Illegal Orders

[Kathianne]

Oops I forgot about the Mexican-American War actually being a declared war.

I understand the thought that the POTUS should not have the power to unilaterally send our military into action; but the COTUS in fact does make him the commander in chief, and does not limit military engagements to declared wars only.

I would concur however that perhaps the Congress should vote on war or not when the POTUS feels military action is justified, but what if just as a political statement they vote no ? Then you have a POTUS who is either cut off at the knees OR you see a POTUS engaging in military action with a public "we do not agree" from Congress.

I just think it's better the way it is.

I'll go along with the CIC having the right to call up military response, but that if the response is going to last more than say 90, Congress must approve of that by a declaration. There shouldn't be any increase in funding for military after the 90 days, without said approval.

[ConHog]

I'll go along with the CIC having the right to call up military response, but that if the response is going to last more than say 90, Congress must approve of that by a declaration. There shouldn't be any increase in funding for military after the 90 days, without said approval.

Agreed 100%. That is the law and it should be followed.

[KartRacerBoy]

Oops I forgot about the Mexican-American War actually being a declared war.

I understand the thought that the POTUS should not have the power to unilaterally send our military into action; but the COTUS in fact does make him the commander in chief, and does not limit military engagements to declared wars only.

I would concur however that perhaps the Congress should vote on war or not when the POTUS feels military action is justified, but what if just as a political statement they vote no ? Then you have a POTUS who is either cut off at the knees OR you see a POTUS engaging in military action with a public "we do not agree" from Congress.

I just think it's better the way it is.

ConHog, you should read "Bomb Power," a book I listed in my Non-Fiction thread. It's entertaining on this issue.

[ConHog]

ConHog, you should read "Bomb Power," a book I listed in my Non-Fiction thread. It's entertaining on this issue.

I'll check it out.


I know my stance here seems to be in conflict with my beliefs in a small federal government , but damn if the US doesn't stand for protecting those who need protection. What does she stand for?